
Is
Cash Value Life Insurance
A Good Savings Vehicle?
If you need the life insurance
protection for your family, is cash value life insurance a good
savings vehicle for you?
It's the question of the ages!
Over the past 40 years or more there
has been a lot of questions, discussions and heated debates as to
whether or not buying permanent life insurance makes sense.
The primary argument generally revolves around whether you'll have
more money when buying permanent life insurance, compared to using some
other investment vehicle? However, there is a lot more
involved then just how much money you'll have... How long will you
need the insurance protection? What do you want the money for?
How long before you will need the money? What income tax
bracket will you be in when you retire, and more?
In this brief article we're only going
to focus on what seems to be the primary issue for most people...
whether or not you'll have more money when buying permanent life
insurance, compared to other investment vehicles?
So, the
first question is... What are you comparing the cash
accumulation in the cash value life insurance to? Are you buying
term and investing the difference in; mutual funds, stocks,
qualified plans, non-qualified plans, municipal bonds, corporate
bonds, government bonds, treasury certificates, mortgage notes, CDs,
etc?

Most people are being mislead into believing that by investing in the stock market or mutual funds they can earn an average annual return of 10%
and that cash value life insurance will only average around 4-5%.
Logically an investment that averages 10% is going to accumulate
a lot more money than something earning only 4-6%.
Unfortunately, the comparison of
investment returns isn't
that simple. There is a lot of misinformation,
grandiose claims and important information to sort through and
consider... such as actual realistic investment returns,
annual fees and expenses, withdrawal penalties, income taxes, tax deferral, tax
free income, cost of insurance, internal rates of return, ages,
health rating, smoker, non-smoker, male, female, etc. These
are all extremely important points for you to consider when
determining if buying permanent life insurance makes sense for you.
Let's assume you are male age 45.
You need and want $250,000 of life insurance. You are a
non-smoker, in good health. And you have $6,000 to spend each
year for the next 20 years.
If 20 years ago you had purchased a 20 year term policy,
with $250,000 of death benefits, the policy would have cost you about $760
per year. That would have left you about $5,240 to invest each
year. The question is where would you have invested that money?
How about if you had invested in growth mutual
funds, inside of a 401k or IRA, like most people did...
Let’s take a look at the past 48 years to put investing in growth
mutual funds into its proper perspective.
In the 60’s the S&P 500 Index had an
average annual return of 4.39% over those 10 years.
In the 70’s the S&P 500 Index had an
average annual return of 1.60% over those 10 years.
In the 80’s the S&P 500 Index had an
average annual return of 12.59% over those 10 years.
In the 90’s, we had one of the best
times in the history for the U.S. stock market. The S&P 500 Index
had an average annual return of 15.31%.
If you had actually received annual
returns comparable to those of the S&P 500 Index during those 40
years (1960 though 2000) you would have averaged 8.33% per year.
However, when you consider that the
vast majority of
mutual funds didn’t even come close to matching the S&P 500
Index over those 40 years, and then you subtract the annual
fees of 2.5-4.05%, it gives you an entirely different view of the
validity and benefits of investing in mutual funds.
And, we haven’t even considered that from the beginning of 2000
through 2008, the S&P 500 Index had a total loss of (-38.53%)… or
average annual loss of (-5.90%) over those 8 years.
If you add in the last 8 years, the
average return for the S&P 500 Index over the past 48 years is only
5.82%. Now, subtract average expenses of 3.0% and your net return
is only 2.82%. And, that’s only if you were lucky enough to have
found a mutual fund that performed as well as the S&P 500 Index
during those 48 years.
The '2007 Dalbar Report' tracked
investor's behavior in chasing market returns. This report showed
that over a twenty-year period (1987-2006), the average investor
only earned 4.3% during a period where the S&P 500 yielded 11.8%.
And, remember that was in one of the best times in history for the
stock market! And,
it doesn't include the recent stock market downturn in 2008.
So, if you had purchased a $250,000, 20 year term
policy, at $760 per year and then invested the difference of $5,240 annually
into a 401k, (No Match) or IRA, with an average annual return of 4.3%,
(From The Dalbar Report) during those 20 years (1987-2006) you would have
had $167,909. And,
all of the income you'd take would be taxable. If you were to
withdraw $8,395 per year, based on a 33%
income tax bracket (state and federal)
you would get
to spend only $5,625.
_________________________________
However, if you had purchased a
good $250,000 traditional universal life or whole life back then, and invested the
entire $6,000 a year into a policy earning 6% you'd have $166,059.
Even though you'd have slightly less money, you could take $8,303 of income each year... income tax free!
That’s
about 68% more money for you to spend!
And, if you could have purchased a
$250,000 index universal life back then, and you had invested the
entire $6,000 each year into the policy at a rate of 7.55% you'd have
$208,608. You could take $10,430 of income each year... income tax free!
That’s almost double the amount of spendable income you’d have,
compared to investing in a 401k or IRA!
Just based on the numbers, it appears cash
value life insurance can make a lot of sense for most people.
And, that doesn't consider the many
other unique advantages of cash value life insurance...
-
Unlike
qualified plans, there are no caps (limits) on how much money
you can save each year. (You are only limited by the size of
the policy.)
-
Your
cash values accumulate tax deferred.
-
You have
a liquid ‘emergency fund’ for life’s unexpected events.
-
The cash
values can be accessed income tax-free and penalty free prior to
age 59½.
-
Cash
value life insurance is not attachable by creditors.
-
Cash
value life insurance doesn’t count as an asset when you apply
for college financial aide.
-
By over
funding a cash value life insurance policy, up to the MEC
guidelines, it can become “investment grade life insurance.”
(Missed Fortune Concept)
-
The cash
accumulated in your policy can provide you with a tax-free
income in retirement. (Taking withdrawals up to the cost basis
and then borrowing the remainder)
-
You’ll
have the protection of life insurance in your retirement years,
to replace lost pension and social security income at your
death… ('Pension Max' concept)
-
Unlike
qualified plans and annuities, the death benefits and cash
values are transferred income tax free to your beneficiaries.
-
Cash
value life insurance generally bypasses probate. (And it is
private, no public records)
-
Cash
value life insurance can be used to pay income taxes on
qualified plans and your estate taxes at your death.
-
Safety - All 50 states have
something similar to FDIC for life insurance policies and
annuities... Plus, insurance companies must, by law, cover at
least 100% of their liabilities with reserves, hence the term
“100% legal reserve life insurance company.” There are also
regulations as to the percentage that can be held in certain
forms of assets. This system has produced a remarkable overall
record of solvency and safety.
-
Guarantees - Only Life
Insurance and Annuities guarantee your investment principle, and
offer you minimum growth guarantees for the life of the
contract.
If you need life insurance and can get similar returns to the
stock market without the risks, more guarantees, tax free income, plus many more
benefits, then why wouldn't you buy cash value life insurance?
Yours In Success,
Lew and Jeremy Nason
'The 9 Out Of 10 Guys'
____________________________

Message
to Financial Advisors…
You have a great opportunity to
really help your prospects to weather this last financial storm and
help them to enjoy a rich life now and in the future.
People need and want your help to achieve the financial security
they’ve been dreaming about and deserve. Aren’t life insurance
and
annuities a way for us to give these middle-income families the
safety, guarantees and growth they are looking for? When
are you going to get back to the basics and start actually helping
people, instead of just trying to make a sale? Jeremy
and Lew Nason